Sept. 11, 2024
You know what the problem with referral programs are? They come with hidden costs that can eat into your bottom line. In today's competitive world, businesses using referral marketing have one more thing to add to the list of their worries: referral fraud. This is a costly scheme that can foil your growth strategy. Many businesses struggle with self-referral fraud, account cycling, and other unscrupulous activity that skews your numbers, empties your coffers, and tarnishes your good name. In this post I'm going to peel back the layers of referral fraud prevention and show you what really prevents it from happening. When you understand what referral fraud is, you can safeguard your referral marketing and have a more dependable customer acquisition channel, resulting in a stronger brand and fuller wallet.
Referral fraud is a big problem for companies who use referral marketing. It's when shady people game these programs by creating fake traffic or fake accounts to earn rewards without doing any real work. When people engage in referral fraud, they are effectively hacking the system for cash, and it hurts companies that are trying to acquire real referrals to grow.
Fraudsters have a lot of tactics up their sleeve to cheat referral programs, but one of their favorite practices is self-referral. That's when they create many accounts to refer themselves and earn referral rewards over and over without ever making a genuine referral. Account cycling takes place when the fraudster refers an account they referred themselves and cycles through different accounts in order to continue receiving rewards. Fake account creation happens when individuals make multiple false identities to cash in on referral rewards.
But these fraudulent behaviors have real business consequences, leading to financial losses where fraudsters receive free rewards without driving any true value for the company, muddying up attribution and making financial forecasting a real headache. And once customers find out that a company has been defrauded in this way it could be extremely damaging to the company's reputation, trust, and more generally, market integrity. For example, if a company is known to have a high rate of referral fraud, potential buyers would be less likely to convert, assuming the company is dishonest and wouldn't honor their referral rewards.
For customer acquisition, businesses leveraging referral programs for their acquisition efforts need to be familiar with referral fraud. The digital space is always changing, and fraudulent behavior is becoming increasingly sophisticated, so it's important for businesses to understand how to identify and stop it.
Steps to prevent referral fraud can include features like limits built into referral programs to control promo code validity, reward value, and volume of referrals.
Another effective approach is to include a holding period between when a customer claims the referral and when rewards are paid out. This gives Trust and Safety teams time to collect and analyze conversion data.
Frequent and regular updates to the terms and conditions of referral programs help to eliminate potential abuse opportunities.
Businesses can also use link analysis to visualize possible suspicious activity and deploy velocity checks to detect anomalies in account creation and transaction frequency.
Bot detection solutions such as CAPTCHAs prevent automated fraudulent activity, and strict know-your-business (KYB) checks for affiliate partners can help validate their legitimacy and track chargeback rates.
Understanding the full scope of referral fraud helps businesses to build a more complete approach that safeguards their investment and their reputation.
Preventing referral fraud helps businesses protect their acquisition investments and keep them paying off longer.
To have a successful referral program, you need to understand referral fraud prevention. Marketing strategies have evolved, and so have the tactics for gaming those systems. When we understand the various types of referral fraud - self-referring, broadcasting, account cycling, and others - we can recognize it when it happens and understand the impact on our business.
Referral fraud isn't always other people referring fake customers to your business to get a reward. In fact, self-referral fraud is a type of scam that can damage the integrity of referral programs. People with bad intent will create multiple accounts, often with subtle variations, to work around any limits the business has in place. Real referrals are a community achievement. Self-referral distorts the referral ecosystem by inflating metrics and allocation of resources. These fraudsters will exploit single-sided rewards to receive goods for themselves without doing the job of referring new customers. This is very common in programs that don't take a lot of care in verifying newly-referred accounts. One person pretending to be many people in order to "refer" themselves to maximize their bonuses and cost the business money (because those are not real customers). Recognizing this activity can help the business develop strategies to cut down on this type of fraud by making it more difficult to earn a reward from a referral.
Account cycling is a type of fraud that people use to game referral systems. People will create an account under one person and claim their referral reward—and then return items for a refund, effectively gaming the system while the business gets returns. This can happen over and over and can desensitize the referral reward system.
This kind of fraud is especially bad because it's not just embezzling the economics of referral programs—it's distorting sales. Businesses will need to implement additional safeguards like delaying rewarding until product fulfillment or instituting a return window before an account can re-earn the reward. All to try to deter people who are gaming the system.
Beyond just normal fraud, there are fraudsters out there who will always look for and exploit gaps in your referral program terms to cheat you. Stuff like discount sharing, affiliate fraud, and so on.
So, for example, if you have a discount available for referrals and aren't careful, scammers can exploit the system by referring themselves and receiving multiple discounts even though there's no actual customer acquisition. And they can do this because you allow it!
Knowing about these gaps will let you write better and stronger referral terms. Having solid, airtight copy, and strong terms designed to guard against exploitation, will make your programs more fair.
Understanding the different types of referral fraud is key if you want to be able to effectively prevent it. Each type has its own unique challenges and will require its own set of solutions. Marketers who are clear about what constitutes a valid referral, and have checks and balances in place, will naturally do a better job of preventing people from gaming the system. By knowing and preparing for all possible ways people can game your referral program, you can turn referral programs from a potential landmine into a profitable marketing channel that can drive real customer engagement.
Referral fraud is one of the biggest issues businesses face in today's digital world. It happens when people manipulate the referral system, and the impacts can be huge for companies—from financial losses to a damaged reputation. Understanding how referral fraud impacts you is important for businesses who want to maximize the potential of their referral marketing efforts and do so profitably and legitimately.
Referral fraud creates a lot of fake data that's really hard to see through. When people game referral programs, you have fake data. That fake data will throw off your attribution metrics, and you'll never be able to accurately forecast based on it. For instance, if you think you really did get a lot of real referrals, you might scale up based on that false positive. Which generally means you're going to spend your time and/or money, and have nothing to show for it. Businesses make decisions based on data, so when there's referral fraud in the mix, it can really throw things off. You're going to have to spend resources on good data management and good analytics so that you can still see what's going on and what's real engagement. You can use advanced analytics to view some of these patterns, so you can still make business decisions with a level head.
One thing you notice about referral fraud is definitely the money. No surprises there; generally, a company will be spending money or offering rewards as part of the referral process, and if they're offering rewards in exchange for "fake" referrals (i.e., ones that don't actually make the company any money or engage with the company in any way), they're going to end up out-of-pocket. Because they'll be paying more than they'll be making.
If a company offers a $50 reward for every person referred that goes on to become a new customer, if unscrupulous individuals can just create hundreds of dummy accounts, or some kind of automated process, then they can create a lot of fake referrals and claim $50 each. But they're not really doing anything at all. It means the company will need a really strong verification step to be sure that a referred customer is truly a legitimate customer before they agree to pay a reward. That can help control the money aspect, as well as help keep the referral program as a whole looking good.
Customer trust is one of the most valuable things your business can earn. When referral fraud is allowed to spread, it can degrade trust in your brand, creating a poor experience for customers. This can lead to a disappointing experience for your real customers, who could feel misled. If all the referrals look fake, your real customers might end up referring much less, if at all, which could reduce overall participation rates.
Your brand is your business' operational and customer-facing ethos. If tarnished, it can have long-term, far-reaching impacts on customer acquisition, retention, and more. By addressing this issue openly from the outset of your referral program and defining what's acceptable and what's not acceptable, you can immunize yourself from these potential issues. You should articulate the downsides of referral fraud in order to protect trust, and customers refer friends to your business compliantly.
Referral fraud has become more common lately, especially in e-commerce. In 2021, almost 1/5th of all attacks on e-commerce businesses came in the form of referral fraud. That makes it something pretty serious, and businesses need to be pretty serious about it in return.
Knowing referral fraud is an issue today helps e-commerce businesses be more secure in the future, and better understand the industry and what’s good and bad.
Just watching industry trends and being aware can let e-commerce businesses find and fix their own holes before fraudsters have a chance to abuse their referral system. Being aware of your own referral activity isn’t just a security thing; it’s also learning what types of new things fraudsters are doing. By reading a bunch of case studies of companies that successfully handled referral fraud, you can copy what they did to make sure you are doing things the right way.
You want to take a proactive approach to referral fraud, to safeguard your profits and your brand. You want to enable referral fraud detection so you can detect and identify anomalies and suspicious behavior in your referral program. This means being able to monitor referral activity, verify the authenticity of referrals, and respond to suspicious behavior.
You want to stop issues in their tracks. For example, with the appropriate technology, you can monitor referral activity in real-time and flag anything that seems irregular. With regular reviews and reports, you can ensure your referrals are genuine, and you won't be fooled. And you want employees and customers who understand what ethical referrals are all about, so you can establish trust across the entire business. Do all of this, and you'll have a referral program that's all but impenetrable to referral fraud, while maintaining the trust and operational efficiency you've worked so hard to achieve.
Referral fraud is on the rise in many industries, costing big money and prompting the need for tighter controls and best practices. Real customer stories show how fraud happens and what companies are doing to try and stop it.
E-commerce companies are losing money to fraudulent referrals, where the self-referrer competes with the truly referred for rewards, and the company pays expensive ad costs to drive real traffic to websites. And all because they cannot trust that the real user benefited from a referral. According to findings, 23% of coupon codes were misused in a hotel chain case.
That's why many e-commerce companies have been making referral programs less open to abuse, adding barriers to entry—like capping the number of accounts that can be created from a single IP address, and very strict identity verification—in the hopes of limiting the effect of fraudulent referrals. The cost of self-referral fraud isn't just to the bottom line; companies pay in customer trust as real users now have to compete with fraudulent ones.
Ridesharing is a prime example of this: Many ridesharing companies have experienced the frustrating effects of referral fraud—more expensive operations and lower profits. People commit referral fraud when they use referral codes to generate fake accounts that look like real new users, in order to claim the incentive earmarked for real new users (which isn't the desired effect, obviously!). Companies have been forced to change the parameters of their referral programs to protect their financial bottom line. In fact, 27.6% of users used parallel spacing in a shopping app case.
Some ridesharing companies, for instance, have begun imposing a cap on the number of referrals a person can make, and now require the recipient to take a ride or complete some other in-app behavior. This ensures only real new users receive the cash reward, and also represents a heightened level of consideration around what plays a role in acquisition versus what has an impact on fraud that's affecting their bottom line.
When you see how other companies have handled referral fraud prevention, you'll notice some very cool stuff you can use too. They've implemented measures to make it harder for people to game their referral program, by introducing stronger validation measures to require new users to take specific actions before they can be rewarded a referral bonus. It could be something as simple as validating a new account by email or phone number, or ensuring new users complete specific bookings/trips.
This is huge because fraudsters have gotten smarter. It isn't just about fake accounts anymore. They can do other things, like use a VPN or somehow trick the system to create a new account. But with stronger validation, they are able to protect themselves and their brand reputation. These companies are validated, and they don't want people to take advantage of their program. By doing this, they can maintain the integrity of their referral program and ensure that it's only real users that earn the rewards.
The biggest thing to keep in mind from cases like this, and other large scale referral fraud cases, is to stay incredibly vigilant, and have systems and checks in place to catch fraud early. The more verification checks and balances you have in place, the better.
For example, using robust analytics software that can identify irregular patterns in referral traffic, like large spikes in account creations, or irregular user behavior that might signal fraud. Also, working with specialized fraud solutions vendors can help arm you to protect your referral business. When you use solutions that verify user traffic, you can stop the invalid traffic from infiltrating and ruining your marketing campaigns, which in turn protects your bottom line, and your brand.
Referral fraud is a complex problem that will take some creativity and awareness on the part of affected companies. Staying aware and taking proactive steps will be key to ensuring that referral programs can continue to be a benefit, rather than a vulnerability.
Referral programs are great for growing your customer base, but they have the potential for fraud. Here's how to prevent referral fraud so you can secure your referral efforts and keep on growing.
Good referral programs start with strong terms and conditions that clearly spell out who can refer, any restrictions on the referral, and how rewards are acquired. This clarity will enable you to build trust with your customers and help them understand what is expected of them while referring. For example, you might include a clause in your terms of service stating that users are not allowed to create multiple accounts to claim rewards—this is to prevent self-referral and abuse.
You'll also want to update your terms periodically to make sure that they're still effective against new fraud tactics. In having these, you will be in a place to make an environment that the people who do want to game your system are deterred by the risk of getting caught, and the expense of gaming your program.
Advanced fraud detection is key when it comes to keeping an eye on referral activity. Tools that analyze user behavior are able to recognize irregular patterns, like sudden spikes in referral activity, or deviations from the norm, that could indicate something is amiss, such as an unexpectedly high number of referrals coming from the same IP address, or a surge in new accounts being created in the wake of a referral program launch.
Algorithms and AI let businesses take preventive action against suspicious behavior, fortifying their defenses against referral offer abuse, while timely alerts ensure that the right people know straightaway, so they can act fast in response to the risk of fraud.
Limit the number of referrals someone can make to cut down on low-effort fraud. You can, for example, make bonuses payable only after new customers reach a spending threshold, so you'll weed out reward-seekers who aren't really interested in you and attract much more valuable referrals—people who are likely to stick with you for the long term.
Of course, these rules need to be simple for the customer to follow, and they need to work. Get that balance right, and you'll keep users incentivized to refer and make it more difficult for fraudsters to game your program.
Referral Fraud Prevention
That’s an easy one. I’ve got to start with the most straightforward thing on the list first: referral fraud prevention. I mean, if people aren’t searching for that precise term, what will they be searching for? “How to make sure people don’t game my referral program?”
But other than that, I also want to go after other permutations like “how to prevent referral fraud” and “stopping referral fraud” and things like that. Again, not an exact science, just have to try to think like my reader and put myself in their shoes a bit.
1
| Topic | Key Points | Impact | Prevention Tactics |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is Referral Fraud? | Using a referral program in a negative way | Money lost, brand damage | How can you protect your brand from referral fraud? |
| Common Strategies | Self referral, account cycling, fake accounts | Skewed metrics, difficulty forecasting | Limits, verify all the things |
| Types of Referral Fraud | Self referral, broadcasting, account cycling, exploiting loop holes | Inflated metrics, customer dissatisfaction | Clear terms, fraud detection |
| E-commerce Examples | Losing money to self-referrals, fake accounts | High cost of acquisition, brand discount | More validation, more monitoring |
| Ride-sharing outcomes | People misusing referral codes | More operations cost, less margin | Update referral terms, real user engagement |
| Fraud Detection | What can monitor provide that pro-active system don't? | Keep your money, keep your brand | Advanced analytics, fraud vendor partnerships |
| Protecting Your Program | Clear terms, fraud detection tools, referral limits | Protect your referral program while growing | Educate your team, check in often, mix it up |
Referral fraud is a big headache for companies with referral programs. We'll explain what it is, how it happens, and what kinds of negative effects it can have on your business. Different types of fraud like self-referral, broadcasting, cycling, etc. can be detrimental to not only your profits, but your customer relationships and brand, as well. Protect yourself by understanding the issue and setting up as many protective measures as possible. Clearly outline your program's terms, utilize fraud detection tools, set referral limits, and perform regular audits on your referral stream. By patching up these vulnerabilities in your referral stream now, you can protect your company's wallet and reputation, all while capturing genuine customer engagement.
Referral fraud occurs when people try to manipulate referral marketing programs to receive a reward for nothing, without ever referring any new customers. It can be expensive for businesses, it can distort data and analytics, and it can look really bad.
There are three main methods that people use: self-referral, where people make multiple accounts and refer themselves; account cycling, where they refer accounts they have made themselves; and outright fraud, making fake accounts to get more referrals. All three types are fraudulent, defraud the referral system and cost businesses money.
Understanding referral fraud will help you develop strategies to prevent it from undermining your marketing. And save you money. And protect your customers' trust.
Prevention strategies include clear terms and conditions for referral programs, using fraud detection tools, setting referral limits, and conducting regular audits. You can also train employees to identify fraudulent behavior and communicate clear guidelines.
Referral fraud can ruin customer trust because genuine participants may become disengaged or feel cheated if fraud is present, and a bad reputation generally leads to reduced acquisition and retention, which will hurt the business in the long run.
Referral fraud is widespread in e-commerce—some studies find that X% of fraudulent attacks target e-commerce businesses. So e-commerce businesses need to be especially vigilant about their referral system and take measures to stop it.
A good referral program should have crystal-clear eligibility requirements, robust fraud detection, limits on referral incentives, and checks to make sure you're not being taken advantage of. Educating employees and customers can help ensure your program is fair to everyone.
These folks are going to need a lot of verification on new accounts-- email or phone, and certain customer actions-- before they'll qualify for rewards. This is a good thing. It helps build trust and ensures referred friends are legitimate.
referral fraud prevention discussion in a business setting
SMS Check